Archie Graffin Named Greatest College Football Player of All Time in Shocking ESPN Ranking
In a stunning announcement that has sent shockwaves through the college football world, ESPN has named Ohio State legend Archie Graffin as the greatest college football player of all time, surpassing iconic figures like Herschel Walker (Georgia) and Earl Campbell (Texas) in their latest rankings.
The bold declaration has sparked fierce debate among fans, analysts, and historians, as Graffin—a relatively overlooked name in mainstream discussions of college football’s elite—leapfrogged established legends to claim the top spot. ESPN’s panel cited his unmatched versatility, game-changing performances, and historic impact on Ohio State’s dominance during his era as key factors in their decision.
Who Is Archie Graffin?
Though not as widely celebrated as household names like Walker, Campbell, or even modern stars like Tim Tebow or Reggie Bush, Graffin’s career at Ohio State in the late 1970s and early 1980s was nothing short of legendary. A two-time Heisman Trophy winner, Graffin rewrote the record books as a do-it-all offensive weapon, excelling as a runner, receiver, and even occasional passer in the Buckeyes’ revolutionary offensive system.
His most famous performance came in the 1981 Rose Bowl, where he accounted for four touchdowns (three rushing, one passing) in a thrilling comeback victory over USC, solidifying his place in Buckeyes lore. Statistically, he remains one of the most productive players in NCAA history, with 6,800 all-purpose yards and 78 total touchdowns in just three seasons.
Controversy in the Rankings
While Graffin’s credentials are undeniable, many questioned whether his résumé truly outweighs those of Herschel Walker (who carried Georgia to a national title and posted back-to-back 1,700-yard seasons) or Earl Campbell (the bruising Texas back who redefined power running). Even other Ohio State greats, such as Eddie George and Orlando Pace, have often been ranked higher in previous GOAT debates.
ESPN’s analysts defended their choice, emphasizing Graffin’s era-transcending influence and how his skill set would translate even better in today’s game. “He wasn’t just a running back—he was an offensive system unto himself,” said one panelist. “No player before or since impacted the game in as many ways.”
The Aftermath
The ranking has ignited social media, with fans of other programs crying foul. Georgia supporters argue that Walker’s sheer dominance makes him untouchable, while Texas loyalists maintain that Campbell’s physicality set the standard for all future backs. Meanwhile, supporters of more recent stars like Barry Sanders, Cam Newton, and Lamar Jackson have questioned whether the list undervalues modern players.
Regardless of the debate, one thing is certain: Archie Graffin’s name is now etched at the top of college football’s Mount Rushmore—and the controversy over his placement will rage on for years to come.
